Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Michael Deimling's avatar

Cheese 90's Rock Band Column? MY JAM CRAIG

Important context to 1998. Boy Bands (and Girl Bands) were blowing up EVERYWHERE. Everything was way overproduced. The MTV "Marketing and Hype Machine" was at full apex. Any band emerging from that specific period that survives today only survived cause they flew under the radar just enough. Hooray for Death Cab - way to be good but just not marketable ENOUGH.

I recall when they hit big that there were those comparisons to the grunge giants that came before. And the backlash too. Candlebox says hello. It didn't help too that at first they were perceived or marketed as a 'Christian' band and their origin story. It was all packaged up so nicely by MTV that they were never going to get any respect long term.

Devils advocate - there are some good/great pop rock jams in their catalog. The lyrics might not be Dylan level (eyeroll) but they aren't Nickelback either. There's some deep relatable stuff there. The irony of the MTV backlash was that after about 2 years everyone wrote them off as posers and fakes, when all those self loathing lyrics and dark themes Scott Stapp sang (wrote?) ended up as completely authentic when we all realized how fucked up he really was.

Full disclaimer - not an odd ball cheese 'bucket list' band cause I saw them in Allstate Arena (Chicago) in 2001.

Expand full comment
Shaggy Snodgrass's avatar

From a musical perspective (i.e. absent Mr. Stapp), Creed's Mark Tremonti was extremely skilled at pulling tasteful, anthemic "feels" out of the relatively novel at the time "down-" or "drop-" tunings for guitar. Those tunings had certainly been done before; but they'd never really been mined for "hooks" and uplifting "feels" the way Tremonti did. In a sense, those feels kinda contributed to the overall "cringe" effect folks look back on them now with; but in their time they were both awesomely effective and innovative. MT's later work, with the much better singer Myles Kennedy in Alter Bridge, was often stunningly great; but the times had shifted beyond that style by then, + Bridge seems destined to be forever underrated because of that. One more case of the "When" being more important than the "What" in rock and roll.

Expand full comment

No posts